TheTimesTribune.com, Corbin, KY

Editorials

August 23, 2010

Even the founding fathers had an agenda

CORBIN — Perhaps the greatest collection of genius in one place at one time took place in Philadelphia in 1787 — the Constitutional Convention. We too often fail to appreciate how revolutionary, subversive and radical their ideas are.

But we too frequently treat the “Founding Fathers” as infallible moral authorities and all sides appropriate them for contemporary political reasons. They were brilliant, farsighted and courageous, but they were mortal, fallible — and sometimes acted on self-interest and in partisan ways.

The next time someone quotes Thomas Jefferson on the Constitution, recall he wasn’t there. He was in France, urging on their bloody revolutionaries and trying to woo a young married woman. Go back and read his correspondence with James Madison during that period. Jefferson questioned the adoption of a new government. He preferred to strengthen — slightly — the Articles of Confederation. Read Jefferson’s thoughts on “a nation of yeoman farmers” before adopting him as an authority to oppose farm subsidies. Both Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton were members of George Washington’s cabinet, yet both undermined Washington’s foreign policy, each flirting with treason by encouraging French (Jefferson) and British (Hamilton) intrigue.

Madison’s “Publius” argued for a strong central government in The Federalist Papers. Yet after the Constitution was ratified, he and Jefferson wrote the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, arguing a state could exercise its sovereignty to disregard federally enacted laws. But President Madison later opposed the idea when New England states wanted to nullify embargoes and customs laws used to finance the War of 1812. Jefferson believed the Louisiana Purchase was unconstitutional — but that didn’t stop him.

Jefferson is sometimes invoked by those defending unregulated free markets and even Wall Street where self-described “Titans of the Universe” move paper around to make fortunes. Jefferson despised “stock-jobbers,” the derisive term he used to dismiss Hamilton’s financial system. That system, by the way, was based entirely upon government debt and credit. But Jefferson acquiesced when he cravenly traded votes for Hamilton’s plan to assume state debts in exchange for locating the national capitol in Washington.

Nevada Senate candidate Sharon Angle recently said Washington, Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin were “conservatives.” Well they were so conservative, they engaged in armed revolution. Jefferson was forever in debt, spending far beyond his means on fine French wines, books and furniture. He’s believed to have fathered children by a slave who could hardly say no. Franklin maintained a second family during his stay in Britain, fathered an illegitimate child who in turn fathered one of his own. Franklin expressly denied the divinity of Jesus and Washington and Jefferson seemed at times to question it. Franklin used the Postal Service to get rich and secure a government job for his son. Jefferson and Madison used government funds to bankroll a newspaper to promote their political agenda and attack opponents. All at one time or another owned other human beings — although Franklin later became an abolitionist and Washington freed his slaves upon his death.

These men and others created a revolution second only to that incited by Jesus. Unlike Jesus, they were imperfect. Their foibles and humanity don’t detract from their accomplishment. Their ideas and ideals remain the best guides for how we should govern ourselves. They are due our reverence and gratitude —but not our worship.

We would be wise to remember they would not recognize the world in which we live. Next time an opponent of the health care reform quotes one of those revolutionary titans, remember they believed an effective medical treatment for most illnesses was to bleed patients with leeches, a remedy which may have killed Washington.

Ronnie Ellis writes for CNHI News Service and is based in Frankfort, Ky. He may be contacted by email at rellis@cnhi.com. Follow CNHI News Service stories on Twitter at www.twitter.com/cnhifrankfort.

Text Only
Editorials
  • Carl Keith Greene.jpg Presidential presumptions

    Well, the primary election is complete. Now’s the time to plan for the November general election.

    May 24, 2012 1 Photo

  • Don McNay.jpg Autism and my grandson’s first swim

    My 11-year-old grandson took his first trip off the diving board last week. Two weeks previously, he couldn’t swim at all.

    May 22, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0602 Tim Mills Do not stand around; get involved today

    The publishing of the news, blogging of stories, posting of videos and the use of today’s communication tools has really changed the landscape of our world. Thirty years ago, television as we know it did not even exist. The real means of communication was radio.

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • 0203 Willie Sawyers.jpg Broken-home Bob becomes top dog

    In the span of a few days, Broken-home Bob went from sharing a home with three other dogs to romping on a farm in Hazel Green, eating steak off the grill and becoming top dog in a new family.

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • Ronnie Ellis.jpg There could be more at stake than a congressional seat

    If Secretary of State Alison Lundergan Grimes’ calculations are correct, a small number of voters in northern Kentucky could have a big impact Tuesday on the future of the Republican Party of Kentucky. Based on past elections and absentee ballots, Grimes suggests only about 12 percent of voters may turn out.

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • jim waters Some barbershop wisdom for government regulators


    The randomness of occupational licensing regulations in Kentucky, especially for jobs often filled by lower-income citizens, has specific – and unfortunate – consequences.

    May 18, 2012 1 Photo

  • Carl Keith Greene.jpg A summer of parks and history

    Well, it’s the middle of May, and it seems that we’ve had spring and summer already.

    May 17, 2012 1 Photo

  • David Mitchell was Lynn Camp football

    It’s going to be weird not seeing David Mitchell pace up and down the Lynn Camp Wildcat sidelines during the fall.

    May 15, 2012

  • 0602 Tim Mills Opportunity is yours

    Opportunity is something that you hear a lot about today. Politicians like to talk about opportunity and there is no shortage of thoughts from the presidential camps on this topic.

    May 14, 2012 1 Photo

  • John Burkhart.jpg Hope for lost land and lives

    “Gullies so big you could bury a horse,” are words I heard as a child raised in hillside farming country.

    May 14, 2012 1 Photo