TheTimesTribune.com, Corbin, KY

Letters

Discussion

August 25, 2010

To exterminate a nation

The Times-Tribune

CORBIN — Dr. Benjamin Spock said many years ago that the only way we could win in Vietnam was to exterminate a nation. Possible. However, it certainly seems true about the war in Afghanistan. We compare it to Iraq where we have claimed victory, but the situation is different. The population there of Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds enabled us to form or purchase an alliance with some of them. And it is probably that when we finally withdraw our forces, if we ever do, the present government will be replaced with one that is unfriendly to us.

In Afghanistan, the people we are fighting are of a common cultural heritage, and their main reason for fighting us is that “we are there.” Additionally, a good general would never pick such a battlefield where the enemy can attack us from ambush and hid in population areas where the rules of engagement prevent us from shooting back.

Presumably, that would be the reason why none of the countries which have warred with Afghanistan over the past thousand years have prevailed. Unfortunately, our generals have not been given much choice by the politicians who manage them. Osama bin Laden said years ago that it was good to have us over there because it was so much easier to kill us.

After 9/11, we deployed a few hundred military personnel to Afghanistan. Their job was to ally with the “northern alliance” against the Taliban and coordinate targeting for U.S. air strikes. Within two months, we had won at that, and the anti-terrorist message was well understood throughout the world, as demonstrated when Libya gave up its nuclear weapons program. At that point, we should have left Afghanistan. But we stayed. Was it to give a democratic government to a tribal people who didn’t understand democracy and didn’t want it? Or was it to expand the American empire?

Bottom line. The trillion dollar cost of our mid-east military operations is a major factor in our current path to national bankruptcy, together with the trillions spent and committed by the present administration on socialist projects in federalizing major parts of our economy. We also have a major morale problem where some two thirds of our people want us out of these wars in which we have no security interest.

Our forces have had a very high rate of serious injury including train trauma from roadside bombs, which the Veterans Administration estimates in the tens of thousands.

We also have a very high rate of suicide among military personnel. Perhaps this relates to the frequent re-deployment of the same military units to the mid-east, but also to the fact that our reason for being there is political, not national security. Our people understand, but those in government who call themselves public servants apparently do not.

While our economic and military strength has been substantially reduced by the mid-east wars, Russia and China which still seek to dominate the world in a communist police state, will no longer still see us as a credible adversary. Our politicians should change their outlook from the next five minutes to the foreseeable future and know that the world will realize that our terminating these useless wars is not a matter of losing them because we still have the capability (which we would never use) to “exterminate a nation.”

President Coolidge said, “Perhaps the most important accomplishment of my administration has been minding my own business.” And president John Quincy Adams said, “It is not our nation’s role to go about the worlds in search of nations to destroy.”

Col. Harold V. Walsh, USAF, Ret.

New Haven, Ky.

Text Only
Letters
  • 0210 Patricia Turner Tom Jenson.jpg Call your representatives and ask them to support Senate Bill 87

    On Jan. 31, Brian and Martha Reeves, Larry Davenport, Mark Turner and Irene Roark and I joined other groups of Disability Rights advocates to teach Kentucky’s State Legislators in Frankfort about Newsline, an electronic information service for the blind and otherwise print-impaired Kentuckians.

    February 10, 2012 1 Photo

  • Bootleggers use community outrage to stay in business

    I would like to weigh in on the issue of the legal sale of liquor in the city of Corbin. The way I see it, all the objections seem to be coming from the bootleggers through the churches.

    February 10, 2012

  • Please stop killing other people’s pets

    Over the past three months, I have seen an increase of both cats and dogs that have died from being struck by drivers. What makes this such a sad thing is that most of the time the driver will pick up speed and aim for them just to hit and kill them or injure them badly enough that they will eventually die on their own or from other drivers who also enjoy running over them.

    February 10, 2012

  • Alcohol devastates and destroys lives

    To Knox County Constable Carl Bolton, I forgive you. You were honest when you admitted you broke the law when you drove while under the influence of alcohol. You even acknowledged that you were blessed, as were others, by the police officer who did his job. Thank you for accepting responsibility for your actions.

    February 10, 2012

  • A thank you to Rep. Jim Stewart

    In a time of budget cuts, time constraints and tight deadlines, it is unusual to find someone who takes the time to care about kids. However, on Jan. 12, at the Capitol, Rep. Jim Stewart welcomed a group of fifth- and sixth-grade students from Corbin Intermediate School and exchange students from Hong Kong’s Taoist Ching Chung Primary School.

    January 31, 2012

  • What good could possibly come from alcohol sales?

    I want to start by saying that I was born and raised in Knox County. If you would have told me 15 years ago that legalizing alcohol in Barbourville and/or Corbin would be an issue, I would have told you that you were crazy.

    January 25, 2012

  • A chaser for the booze debate

    Why not sell alcohol in Corbin? Here’s the straight and cordial rundown of the answers served by some readers: the Bible says don’t do it; minors will drink; more accidents, crime, “tragedy;” we banned smoking (Whaa?!); and economic analysis favors prohibition. Frankly, the debate has fermented past its prime. Have we not already heard the argument as it hops from one side to the other?

    January 24, 2012

  • Waterways suffer too much pollution

    There is a lot of pollution in our streams and other major waterways. While pollution may not affect the taste of the water we drink, it will affect the health of people and animals.

    January 19, 2012

  • Society forgetting how to interact outside of Facebook

    Our society today is too involved in social media such as Facebook and Twitter, and we are forgetting how to socialize in the real world. Does anyone really talk face-to-face anymore, or do they just socialize with each other online?

    January 19, 2012

  • Alcohol increases chance of tragedy

    The debate of whether Corbin should be a “wet” town has gone on a long while. It seems more than a few people would be overjoyed if this became a reality. However, the possibility of underage drinking and drunk driving would spike quite a bit.

    January 19, 2012